The call
Players ask about this theory, but no creator-confirmed evidence collected for this page says Ratthew should be treated as a reception anomaly. Do not use the theory as an admit or reject rule.
Separate Ratthew's observed character role from the player theory that Ratthew is an anomaly.
Players ask about this theory, but no creator-confirmed evidence collected for this page says Ratthew should be treated as a reception anomaly. Do not use the theory as an admit or reject rule.
Treat each row as a decision clue, not a complete substitute for the rest of your patient check.
Treat Ratthew as a named character unless the game presents a direct anomaly state.
Community speculation is not a decisive patient-check signal.
Separate dialogue and story observations from actual reception mechanics.
Look for creator-owned text or a repeatable in-game state that explicitly changes Ratthew's classification.
Do not reject a patient because of a lore theory.
Revisit the evidence log after an official update or reproducible reveal.